If you’re a tech investor hanging on for dear life, or a vulture scouring the tech crash wreckage for bones to pick, the only question that matters now is what’s priced in?
We think Netflix’s fall from grace provides the perfect opportunity to take a look at the type of process investors might want to think about applying to the current market shakeout.
Our core message is to stay dispassionate, step back and think ahead.
The streamer has lost almost three-quarters of its value since its peak popularity back in November last year.
A lot of that is down to the market’s indiscriminate selling of everything that got a temporary boost from lockdowns.
Netflix has posted a couple of sets of results that were less than inspiring, and growth appears to have come to an abrupt halt, but can so much have changed in less than six months?
Wasn’t it obvious that subscriber growth would slow at some point, unable to keep up the stay-at-home fuelled pace? Apparently not.
Netflix was either massively overvalued in November 2021 or is underpriced today.
If you’re a Netflix bear then feel free to shout “overvalued” and move on. But we recommend taking a moment to think.
It’s always important to stay pragmatic in investing, love and hate shouldn’t play a role.
If it was overvalued in November, the right approach is to ask whether that’s still the case, or whether the stock’s fallen too far?
Stock valuation is all about the future.
The past can inform the future, in terms of whether the company has built solid foundations for growth, but past success has zero bearing on the current stock price.
Forecasting the future and valuing stocks with precision is all but impossible. But by understanding a few basic valuation concepts, it’s simple enough to play around with some numbers and get a rough idea of what the market is thinking (pricing in).
From there it’s about whether you disagree with the market or not.
It’s a four-step process:
Sales for Netflix are a simple function of their subscriber base multiplied by the price they charge.
Right now Netflix has around 220m subs paying about $12 a month, or $144 a year.
We know that, while headline subscriber growth has slowed, it is still growing across the world. And there could be more growth to come, as streaming hasn't fully penetrated everywhere.
We also know that Netflix is raising prices.
We don’t know the exact rate subscribers or prices will increase, but we can guess. That’s what highly paid Wall Street analysts do after all.
Let's guess that both sales and prices grow at 5% a year, which would be way less than Netflix’s historical growth rates, and incidentally around half the current US and UK inflation rates.
In 2032 then, Netflix’s revenue would be roughly $84bn.
The next step is to convert our sales forecast into profit. Cash-based profits like earnings before interest tax and depreciation (EBITDA) tend to be used in this type of exercise.
Netflix has enjoyed an EBITDA margin (EBITDA as a percentage of sales) of around 20% for the last couple of years.
If we shave a couple of percentage points off this margin for ‘conservatism’, another favourite Wall Street term, we can forecast that in 2032 Netflix will produce $15bn in EBITDA (18% of sales).
There’s one last step before lightning hits the clocktower and we need to be doing 80 in our Delorean (admittedly that was travelling forward in time not backwards), which is to pick a multiple.
At the moment the company is valued at about 13x EV/EBITDA (EV is enterprise value), so the business is valued at 13x its cash-based profits (or EBITDA).
Context is important with multiples and 13x is a much lower multiple than Netflix’s valuation has commanded for the last five years or so.
Another healthy dose of conservative forecasting would be to assume this multiple stays the same.
So multiplying our forecast profits or EBITDA of $15bn by 13 gives us a 2032 value for Netflix of $197bn.
This is fun, right?
The last stage of the fun and games is to convert $197bn into today’s money.
This is done by discounting, the opposite of compounding and it involves dividing the future value by a discount rate a number of times (10 times in this case as we’re looking 10 years into the future) to give us an idea of Netflix’s value today.
A rule of thumb in valuation is that 8% is a healthy and ‘conservative’ discount rate to apply to company forecasts.
Discounting $197bn back ten years to today at 8% gives us an enterprise value of $91bn, magically close to Netflix’s current value of $90bn.
If you’re thinking we’ve chosen numbers that make our valuation of Netflix equate to its current price, so we can stay firmly on the fence when it comes to judging whether Netflix is fairly valued, then you’re right. We did.
But the whole point of the exercise is to get a rough idea of how the market or the average investor is viewing Netflix’s future. And we have just achieved that.
If you’re of the opinion that Netflix will grow subscribers or prices by more than 5%, or the company will be more profitable than it is today, then you might think the stock is underpriced.
But, if you think these numbers are too optimistic and don’t agree that we have been conservative, then you might think subscribers and profits are unlikely to grow much at all from here.
In which case your conclusion might be the stock is still overpriced.
There is more to valuing stocks than the exercise we’ve just gone through. But wrapping your arms around current expectations and then deciding whether you disagree is basically valuation in a nutshell.
FWIW we don’t have a strong view either way on Netflix, sorry about that.
This should not be read as personal investment advice and individual investors should do their own research on what investments are right for them or seek independent advice.
When you invest, your capital is at risk. The value of your portfolio, and any income you receive, can go down as well as up and you may get back less than you invest. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future results.
Freetrade is a trading name of Freetrade Limited, which is a member firm of the London Stock Exchange and is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. Registered in England and Wales (no. 09797821).
Freetrade does not provide investment advice and individual investors should make their own decisions or seek independent advice. The value of investments can go up as well as down and you may receive back less than your original investment. Freetrade is a trading name of Freetrade Limited, which is a member firm of the London Stock Exchange and is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. Registered in England and Wales (no. 09797821).Copyright © 2022 Freetrade, All rights reserved. The Apple logo is a trademark of Apple Inc. App Store is a service mark of Apple Inc. Google Play and the Google Play logo are trademarks of Google LLC.
Made with 🍩 in London, Stockholm, Brisbane and Vancouver.