How to find the best stocks and shares ISA

Everything you need to choose the best investment ISA for you.
How to find the best stocks and shares ISA
Updated
April 5, 2022

Table of contents

Your £20,000 ISA allowance will reset come April so it’s a good time to find the best stocks and shares ISA account out there. 

Whether you’re on the lookout for a tax-efficient share dealing account to complement a cash ISA or you’re scouring the web for the cheapest investment platform out there, we’ve got you.

So, grab a coffee, sit back and find out which ISA is best for you. 


What makes a good stocks and shares ISA account?

The best stocks and shares ISA is the one that suits you. It sounds trite but it’s true.

That means looking at both the ISA account itself, as well as what the investment platform behind it is offering.

That’s because the secret sauce behind the best performing stocks and shares ISA is what actually goes in it and how much is taken out in fees. 

So, whether your plan is to buy shares, exchange-traded funds (ETFs) or investment trusts, you need to make sure they’re actually going to be available if you open an ISA with a particular ISA provider.

The last thing you want is to fall in love with a slick investment platform, only to find that you can’t fill your ISA with the assets you want to invest in.

But, away from the stocks to invest in and how the investments inside your stocks and shares ISA perform, there are a few other things to think about when it comes to choosing the best share trading platform and ISA.

Accessibility, tools, guidance and education, customer support, and, as we’ve said - ISA charges, all matter. Here’s what to keep in mind when you’re weighing up the best UK platform for investing in an ISA.

 

Read more:
Stocks and shares ISA rules
15 common ISA myths busted
The (more realistic) ISA millionaire

How to compare stocks and shares ISA providers

Minimum ISA investment amounts

The ISA allowance for the 2022/23 tax year is £20,000. That doesn’t mean you have to invest that amount, it’s just the upper limit to what you can put in your stocks and shares ISA.

But, while that’s the maximum, there might be a minimum you have to invest with certain platforms so it’s worth checking if that level is right for you.

That lower requirement is more common when you’re dealing with cash ISAs but that doesn’t mean it can’t be a requirement for their stocks and shares cousins.

It might not be advertised in flashing lights that there is a minimum you have to invest in a stocks and shares ISA but if there are heavy fees for small account sizes, that might be a platform’s sneaky way of telling you who they want on board. And who they don’t.

Read more: how do stocks and shares ISAs work?

ISA account fees and charges

That’s actually a neat segue into a very important aspect of ISA shopping we’ve alluded to: fees and charges.

Lining up all the traditional UK ISA platforms, newcomers, and robo-advisers beside each other seems like a good way to compare ISA fees. But it can turn into a huge headache when you realise they all offer different things and charge in different ways - percentage fees against fixed ones, for example.

As if by magic, here’s a quick ISA fee comparison table to put it all in context. More broadly though, you should keep a few numbers in mind:

  • The ISA account fee - this might be a flat fee or percentage of your ISA pot
  • Trading fees - often a flat fee, this is how much you’ll pay each time you place a trade
  • Foreign exchange (FX) fees - how much (normally a percentage) the platform will charge you to buy assets listed in foreign markets in foreign currencies
  • Fund fees - these usually apply to ETFs, OEICs, unit trusts and investment trusts. The company running the fund will normally charge a percentage fee and take it monthly


So, while it may be tempting to look for the cheapest stocks and shares ISA out there, stopping your search at the headline charges means you won’t get the full picture.

Factor in what your investing habits are and what assets you’re likely to invest in - if you want to buy shares, it’s not much use to you if low fund dealing charges are an ISA platform’s selling point, while you pay a fixed fee for every share trade you make.

How often you plan to invest is important to consider too. Racking up transaction fees on multiple shares, investment trusts and ETFs each month can end up making the cheapest ISA provider look a lot more expensive.

Have a play around with our ISA calculator to see how the Freetrade ISA fees stack up against the other stocks and shares ISA platforms in the UK.

Transfer in existing ISAs

If you’ve built up a few ISAs over the years with different investment platforms, building societies or banks, it might make sense to bring them all together.

It can be much easier to manage them all in one place and makes working out things like ISA fees less of a struggle.

It could be that you’ve spotted a cheaper ISA option for your needs or you want to buy assets that your current ISA provider doesn’t offer. 

Whatever your reason, it’s important to make sure an ISA transfer is right for you before you make the move. Our guide to ISA transfers could help here. 


ISA account management

Think about what you actually need from your ISA platform. Are you looking for the best trading app or would you prefer a website? 

What do you want to see displayed when you log in? Is it useful if you can see your self-invested personal pension (SIPP) or general investment account (GIA) in the same place?

Thinking about how you plan to interact with the services on offer will help decide if it’s the right ISA platform for you but it’ll also help determine if it really is providing value. 

Are there any services you’ll be paying for but won’t actually use? If you just want the gym membership, there’s no point paying for the pool and fitness classes too.

Have a look at a few options - do you like the way the investment platform displays your account details? If it’s all a bit confusing that’s just another barrier you can do without, especially if another ISA provider can do all the same things but make it all clearer.

Customer service

We've all had times when customer service either makes or breaks the experience. And the likelihood is that when we need to talk to someone it’s not for a casual chat - it’s to get something done. 

That’s why it’s important to have an ISA platform that offers assistance in the way you want it. If you’re a fan of in-app chat or phoning up, make sure that’s what’s on offer.

There’s a lot to be said for a dependable service with knowledgeable staff and decent response times. That might even form part of how you assess whether you’d get value for money or not from your overall ISA account.

Tools

It’s important to have the tools you need when you invest but more doesn’t always mean better. That’s why it’s worth looking at the resources on offer through a very personal lens.

Do you value charting graphs and tools? Are the calculators up to scratch and, importantly, are they all intuitive and easy to use?

If it’s not useful to you or looks confusing enough to put you off using the platform, that’s maybe indicative of the whole proposition being pitched at a different type of investor.

If you aren’t really that bothered about building a chart full of your bollinger bands and Fibonacci numbers, there isn’t much point in looking for a platform that offers them.

ISA stocks to invest in

As we’ve said, the ISA is just the tax wrapper, you’re the one who chooses what investments should go inside it.

If you regularly invest in stocks, investment trusts and ETFs, make sure they’re there when you’re comparing ISA accounts. If the stock list is looking a bit stale, you might find the ones you want to hold just aren’t there or the company might not be equipped to bring new companies and funds into the stock universe.

Another thing to watch out for is if the investment platform lets you buy fractional shares. Some stocks, particularly on the US stock market, can cost $1,000+ which can price out a lot of investors from the get-go. 

Allowing investors to buy fractional shares means you can grab a smaller chunk of the company without having to shell out for a whole share.

Investment guidance and education

It’s one thing to want the cheapest ISA out there with the fanciest tools on offer but it’s more important that you do your best to become a better investor at the same time.

Have a look to see if your investment platform has an ISA guide or a suite of content that will keep you up to date with the stock market and give guidance on how to choose the right assets for your portfolio.

Granted, they won’t know your personal situation so you’re unlikely to find a site that tells you exactly what to do. That’s what financial advisers are for, although a lot of people find they can get everything they need with a bit of research and guidance from articles on ISAs and investing.

That said, if you are having trouble and aren’t comfortable choosing your own investments, a financial adviser could help.

Alternatively, our Learn hub is full of handy articles on how to start investing, ways to make sure your portfolio stays in line with your investment personality, and investment strategies for beginners and experienced ISA investors too.

Our free investing newsletter Honey, and Saturday morning coffee companion Weekend Read, explore everything from how to (realistically) become an ISA millionaire to whether crypto is right for your ISA or not.


DIY or ready-made ISA portfolio?

When we get into investing, a lot of investors fall into one of three buckets: 

  • Do it for me (likely involving a financial adviser or robo-advice platform and limited personal involvement)
  • Do it with me (using guidance and research to learn, then investing through execution-only platforms yourself)
  • Just let me do it (having enough experience to want to take control and looking for the necessary assets and tools yourself)

And the same applies to the assets we put in our ISA accounts. Some of us would rather outsource it all to a professional and some of us can think of nothing better than doing it all ourselves. The good thing is there’s a way to invest for everyone.

Robo-advisers often have a range of ready-made portfolios to choose from, based on the level of investment risk you want to take. Generally, these portfolios are full of exchange-traded funds (ETFs) tracking global markets.

If you still fancy some ready-made options but would like a bit more choice between investment styles and the overall mix of assets, a bigger range of collective investments like ETFs and investment trusts might be attractive.

As a reminder of the difference between the two, an investment trust (or investment company) is a basket of shares chosen by a manager, and listed on the stock exchange for you to buy and sell. 

The trust’s manager aims to beat their chosen benchmark index by selectively choosing stocks, as opposed to an ETF which aims to match the market’s performance.

If you already have an idea of the stocks to buy for your ISA and don’t want an adviser or external fund manager on board, chances are you’re just looking for a handy, low-cost investment platform with a selection of assets to meet your needs.

 

Best stocks and shares ISA providers for beginners

When it comes to initial investment options and tools, less can really be more. 

If you’re a beginner investor, a huge range of charts and bizarrely-named funds can be daunting and paralysing. Like wandering aimlessly down the cereal aisle, often it’s better if someone helps whittle down that choice with you or gives you the building blocks (muesli and cornflakes obviously) and lets you develop your tastes from there.

Back in the investment world, that means keeping it simple. If you’re going for an ISA provider with all the bells and whistles, ask yourself if you know what they are, how they’d aid your learning and if they’re worth paying for.

There seems to be the perception that, as you get better at investing you suddenly need more complicated analytic tools and charts. Ironically, often the best investors keep it as simple and repeatable a process as possible.

Whatever level you’re at, being confused is never a positive. So look for an ISA platform that doesn’t make you feel stupid, offers the investment universe you need, and the guidance to help you become a better investor.

Everyone has their own goals and unique financial circumstances so you really need to make sure your ISA providers suit you when you also factor in your tolerance for investment risk and time horizon. 

Our resource hub for investing in the stock market might be able to help make that blend a bit clearer for you and our guide on how to invest in stocks is a great start for first-time investors. As we’ve said, if you are still unsure of how to pick investments, speak to a qualified financial adviser. 


How to choose the best stocks for your stocks and shares ISA

The best stocks for your stocks and shares ISA are the ones that truly match your appetite for risk, investment goals and time horizon.

If you start relying on hunches or stock tips from excited friends down the battlecruiser you’re not factoring in your own financial situation - the vital element in all of this. Don’t put the horse before the cart.

What might suit your personal situation might be completely wrong for someone else, so try to run your own race and make sure your portfolio lets you sleep at night. That last thing you want is to be fretting over a volatile mix of assets when you could have got the right blend by putting yourself first.

Read more: Top 10 stocks and shares ISA investments on Freetrade


Which is the best ISA platform for me?

The best ISA providers offer clear and straightforward tools, guides and investment journeys. And they don’t cost the earth. They let you invest in ETFs, buy fractional shares and do everything else you want to with your annual ISA allowance in a way that suits you and without hidden fees.

Which stocks and shares ISA is best for you depends entirely on what you need from it, whether it will encourage you to be a better investor or will scare you off, and how seamlessly it fits into your everyday life.

If investing in your ISA feels like a huge chore, best saved for a rainy afternoon, there’s something wrong. It shouldn’t feel like an extreme sport but it shouldn’t be something you resent either. The platform itself is a big part of that - it can either fill your head full of jargon or be your go-to source of investment guidance.

Concentrate on the important aspects and match your ISA provider to your money goals as much as you can.


We’ve created one of the UK’s leading stock trading apps to help everyone build their wealth over the long term. Join over 1 million users that have chosen Freetrade for their general investment account, investment ISA or personal pension. x

Important information on SIPPs

SIPPs are a pension product designed for people who want to make their own investment decisions. You can normally only access the money from age 55 (set to rise to 57 from 6 April 2028).

This article is based on current rules, which can change, and tax relief depends on your personal circumstances. When you invest, your capital is at risk.

The value of your portfolio can go down as well as up and you may get back less than you invest.

Before transferring a pension you should ensure you will not lose valuable guarantees or incur excessive transfer penalties. Pensions are usually transferred as cash so you will be out of the market for a period.

Freetrade does not currently offer drawdown products for our SIPP.

Important information

This should not be read as personal investment advice and individual investors should make their own decisions or seek independent advice.

When you invest, your capital is at risk. The value of your portfolio, and any income you receive, can go down as well as up and you may get back less than you invest. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future results.

Eligibility to invest into an ISA and the value of tax savings both depend on personal circumstances and all tax rules may change.

Freetrade is a trading name of Freetrade Limited, which is a member firm of the London Stock Exchange and is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. Registered in England and Wales (no. 09797821).

Related articles

Most read